The long set · Part 1 of 2

Holding the line: aerobic effort over longer sets

Most long sets are lost in the first 200 metres. A practical way to name your effort, pace the opening, and let the set come to you.

8 min read Illustrative data

Most long sets are not lost at the end. They are lost in the first 200 metres, when you feel fresh, the water feels fast, and the pace clock seems to be on your side. By the fourth repeat the arithmetic arrives: the opening was borrowed, and the rest of the set is paying it back.

This note is about the opposite habit. Swimming aerobically over a longer set means choosing an effort you could hold for a long time, starting at it on purpose, and letting the pace be whatever that effort produces. It sounds passive. In practice it is one of the most deliberate things you can do in a pool.

What “aerobic” means at the wall

You do not need a laboratory to work in an aerobic range. You need a few honest checks you can run in the water and at the wall.

  • Breathing stays settled. You can keep your usual breathing pattern, for example every three strokes, without snatching extra breaths at the end of each length.
  • The wall test. At the end of a repeat you could say a short sentence to a lane-mate without gasping between words.
  • Your stroke stays the same shape. Hand entry, length of pull and kick look the same on length eight as on length one.

When any of these slips, the effort has moved above what you can sustain for the rest of the set. That is useful information, not a failure.

Name the effort before you swim it

A simple 1–10 rating of perceived effort works well, as long as you anchor the numbers to things you can feel. The bands below are the ones used throughout this journal.

Effort bands used in these notes

Band Rating (1–10) Breathing Wall test Typical use
Easy 3–4 Relaxed, any pattern Full conversation Warm-up, cool-down, recovery between rounds
Steady 5–6 Settled, pattern holds Short sentences Long repeats, aerobic main sets
Strong 7 Deeper, still rhythmic A few words Shorter repeats, last round of a set
Hard 8–9 Urgent by the finish Not yet Time trials, short fast efforts

The point of naming a band is that you choose it before the repeat starts. “Steady, rating 5” is a plan. “See how it goes” is a negotiation you will lose to adrenaline.

Give the effort a pace anchor

Effort is primary, but a pace range keeps you honest on days when everything feels either wonderful or terrible. A useful anchor comes from a recent continuous swim, such as the 1,000 m time trial described in the second part of this series.

Choose a send-off that gives roughly 15–30 seconds of rest on longer repeats. For 300s at about 2:10 per 100 m, the swim takes about 6:30, so a 7:00 send-off leaves around 30 seconds. Rest that is too short quietly turns an aerobic set into a threshold set.

The first 100 decides the next 500

The table below compares two ways of swimming the same 600 m repeat. The swimmer, pool and rest are identical; only the opening changes.

Two ways to swim a 600 m repeat, split by 100 m Illustrative data

100 m Went out fast Rating Held the line Rating
1 1:58 6 2:09 5
2 2:04 6 2:09 5
3 2:08 7 2:08 5
4 2:12 7 2:08 6
5 2:15 8 2:08 6
6 2:16 8 2:07 6
Total 12:53 12:49
Two ways to swim a 600 metre repeat in a 25 metre pool: 100 metre splits for a fast start and for an even pace (illustrative data) A line chart. The horizontal axis is the 100 metre number, 1 to 6. The vertical axis is the time for each 100 metres, from 1:56 at the bottom to 2:16 at the top, so higher is slower. The fast-start line climbs steeply: 1:58, 2:04, 2:08, 2:12, 2:15, 2:16, for a total of 12:53 and a finishing effort rating of 8. The even-pace line is nearly flat: 2:09, 2:09, 2:08, 2:08, 2:08, 2:07, for a total of 12:49 and a finishing rating of 6. The lines cross at the third 100. All values are illustrative. One 600 m repeat, swum two ways Held the line Went out fast 1:562:002:04 2:082:122:16 Time per 100 m (slower ↑) 123 456 100 m of the repeat Went out fast, 100 number 1: 1:58 Went out fast, 100 number 2: 2:04 Went out fast, 100 number 3: 2:08 Went out fast, 100 number 4: 2:12 Went out fast, 100 number 5: 2:15 Went out fast, 100 number 6: 2:16 Held the line, 100 number 1: 2:09 Held the line, 100 number 2: 2:09 Held the line, 100 number 3: 2:08 Held the line, 100 number 4: 2:08 Held the line, 100 number 5: 2:08 Held the line, 100 number 6: 2:07 1:58 felt easy for two minutes 2:16 · total 12:53 · rating 8 2:07 · total 12:49 · rating 6 2:09
The same 600 m repeat, split by 100 m. Higher on the chart is slower. Illustrative data.
Text description of this diagram

Went out fast (squares): the splits climb at every 100 m, from 1:58 to 2:04, 2:08, 2:12, 2:15 and 2:16. Total 12:53, finishing at a rating of 8.

Held the line (circles): the splits stay almost flat, 2:09, 2:09, 2:08, 2:08, 2:08 and 2:07. Total 12:49, finishing at a rating of 6.

The two lines cross at the third 100 m, where both swims are at 2:08. After that the fast start is the slower swim for the rest of the repeat.

The fast start felt better for about two minutes. It finished four seconds slower and two rating points harder, which means the next repeat starts from a deeper hole. The even version finished faster, and its last 100 was its quickest without ever feeling hard.

Notice that in the even version the effort still rises a little, from 5 to 6. That is normal. The same pace tends to feel harder late in a set, so let the rating drift up by a notch rather than chasing a faster split to prove the set is going well.

Ways to hold the line

Count the first length. If your usual steady count is, say, 18 strokes per 25 m and the first length of a repeat comes in at 16 with a big push-off and a hurried kick, you are already above the band.

Use breathing as a governor. If you cannot hold a calm every-three pattern on a steady repeat, the effort is not steady. Slow down until you can.

Split the repeat in your head. Treat a 600 as three 200s: settle, hold, then allow yourself to lift slightly in the last 100 only if the rating is still 6 or lower.

Read the clock only at the wall. Glance at the pace clock at each 100 if you like, but make decisions about effort on the push-off, not mid-length.

An example long-repeat session

Example workout

Steady 2,500

Total 2,500 m25 m poolabout 55 minutes

  • Warm-up, 500 m: 300 easy swim (rating 3–4), then 4 × 50 as 25 easy / 25 steady, 15 seconds rest.
  • Main set, 1,800 m: 3 × 600 steady (rating 5–6) on about 30 seconds rest. Aim for 100 m splits within 3 seconds of each other. Breathe every three strokes.
  • Cool-down, 200 m: easy, mixed strokes if you like.

If the second 600 drifts more than about 5 seconds per 100 m slower than the first at the same rating, shorten the last repeat to 400 or swap it for 4 × 100 easy-to-steady. A shortened set swum well teaches more than a full set that falls apart.

Writing it down

After the session, note three numbers for each long repeat: the slowest 100, the fastest 100, and your rating at the finish. Over several weeks, the gap between slowest and fastest is a better measure of your pacing than any single time. When that gap shrinks at the same rating, your aerobic control is improving, even if no individual split looks remarkable.